Do Law Enforcement Interactions Reduce the Initiation of Injection Drug Use? An Investigation in Three North American Settings
Abstract
Background: The prevention of drug injecting is often cited as a justification for the deployment of law enforcement and for the continuation of drug criminalization policies. We sought to characterize the impact of law enforcement interactions on the risk that people who inject drugs (PWID) report assisting others with injection initiation in three North American countries.
Methods: Cross-sectional data from PWID participating in cohort studies in three cities (San Diego, USA; Tijuana, Mexico; Vancouver, Canada) were pooled (August 2014-December 2016). The dependent variable was defined as recently (i.e., past six months) providing injection initiation assistance; the primary independent variable was the frequency of recent law enforcement interactions, defined categorically (0 vs. 1 vs. 2-5 vs. ≥6). We employed multivariable logistic regression analyses to assess this relationship while controlling for potential confounders.
Results: Among 2122 participants, 87 (4.1%) reported recently providing injection initiation assistance, and 802 (37.8%) reported recent law enforcement interactions. Reporting either one or more than five recent interactions with law enforcement was not significantly associated with injection initiation assistance. Reporting 2-5 law enforcement interactions was associated with initiation assistance (Adjusted Odds Ratio=1.74, 95% Confidence Interval: 1.01-3.02).
Conclusions: Reporting interactions with law enforcement was not associated with a reduced likelihood that PWID reported initiating others into injection drug use. Instead, we identified a positive association between reporting law enforcement interactions and injection initiation assistance among PWID in multiple settings. These findings raise concerns regarding the effectiveness of drug law enforcement to deter injection drug use initiation.
Related Content
Preventing Injecting by Modifying Existing Responses (PRIMER)
PRIMER is a multi-country study on the impact of different interventions in preventing people who use drugs from initiating others into injection drug use.
ViewRequiring help injecting among people who inject drugs in Toronto, Canada: Characterising the need to address sociodemographic disparities and substance-use specific patterns
As supervised consumption services (SCS) are scaled-up across Canada, information on those who require help injecting is necessary to inform equitable service uptake. We characterised the sociodemographic, structural and drug use correlates of needing help injecting among a cohort of people who inject drugs in Toronto, Canada.
View
Investigating a bidirectional relationship between overdose and provision of injection initiation assistance among persons who inject drugs in Vancouver, Canada and Tijuana, Mexico
To explore a potential relationship between overdose and injection initiation, we assessed temporal associations between experiencing a non-fatal overdose and assisting others in initiating injection drug use among persons who inject drugs in two North American cities - Vancouver, Canada and Tijuana, Mexico.
View
Examining the Gender Composition of Drug Injecting Initiation Events: A Mixed Methods Investigation of three North American Contexts
Using mixed methods across three settings in North America, we investigated the gender composition of injection initiation events and the gendered risk environments in which they occurred.
View
Recent Incarceration and Risk of First-Time Injection Initiation Assistance: A Prospective Cohort Study of Persons Who Inject Drugs
Given the prevalence and harms of incarceration among persons who inject drugs (PWID) and their role in injection drug use initiation, this study aimed to investigate whether recent incarceration influences the likelihood PWID assist others in their first-ever injection.
View
A Fragmented Code: The Moral and Structural Context for Providing Assistance with Injection Drug Use Initiation in San Diego, USA
This study examines the social networks and structural contexts linked with assisting others in initiating injection drug use.
View
Injection Drug Use Trajectories among Migrant Populations: A Narrative Review
This article examines the risk factors for injection drug use initiation that are associated with migration.
View
Increased Non‐fatal Overdose Risk Associated with Involuntary Drug Treatment in a Longitudinal Study with People who Inject Drugs
This article examines the influence of involuntary drug treatment (IDT) on non‐fatal overdose among people who inject drugs (PWID).
View
Cross‐border Migration and Initiation of Others into Drug Injecting in Tijuana, Mexico
This study examines the role of people who inject drugs (PWID) in facilitating the entry of others into injection initiation in settings characterized by cross-border migration that are associated with a unique risk environment.
View
History of Medication-Assisted Treatment and its Association with Initiating Others into Injection Drug Use in San Diego, CA
This article examines whether a history of medication-assisted treatment for people who inject drugs (PWID) is associated with a reduced probability of providing injection initiation assistance.
View
Preventing Injection Drug use Initiation: State of the Evidence and Opportunities for the Future
This article examines the evidence on the prevention of injection initiation to identify emerging intervention strategies and key barriers to effectively controlling the ongoing epidemic.
View
Non-injection Drug Use and Injection Initiation Assistance Among People Who Inject Drugs in Tijuana, Mexico
This article examines the risk factors among people who inject drugs (PWID) for providing assistance to other in injection initiation.
View
The North American Opioid Epidemic: Current Challenges and a Call for Treatment as Prevention
This article explores current challenges to contain the opioid epidemic and calls for various treatments that could reduce the epidemic including the scaling up of medication-assisted treatment (MAT).
View
A Socio-structural Approach to Preventing Injection Drug Use Initiation: Rationale for the PRIMER Study
This study explores the methodology employed in the PRIMER study.
View
From Words to Action: Comparing the Disparities Between National Drug Policy and Local Implementation in Tijuana, Mexico and Vancouver, Canada
This article examines the discrepancies between federal policy and local responses to drug-related harms to understand the impact of national drug policies in shaping local responses to drug-related harms among people who use drugs (PWID).
View